The movie: Aloha (Cameron Crowe, 2015)
Have I seen this movie before? No.
How I saw it: At the Rave Fairfax Corner 14, one of the two theaters in the Washington, DC metropolitan area that are still showing this movie. I took a lovely drive out there to see it on a Sunday night, alone. The things I do for you people. I offer the following picture, a picture that is definitely not a screengrab from one of those ISIS hostage videos, as proof:

The recommender: Vincent Penge
The rationale: The trailer for Aloha is, to borrow a word, trash. The one-note characters (Alec Baldwin as an angry boss! Billy Murray as a Manic Pixie Dream Old Man!) and awkwardly expository dialogue ("Who doesn't want a second chance?"; "You can't pick my brains, they're unpickable!") honestly had me wondering whether this was a romcom genre parody, a la They Came Together. I want John to eviscerate this movie and spare me the cultural tourism of actually watching it myself.
My familiarity with this movie: I, like Vincent, have seen the trailer for this movie, and agreed with his assessment (as I said to FOTB Sam Thomas, after seeing it with her before a different movie, “that trailer was 0% subtext and 100% text”). The reviews (and attendant controversies) lead me to believe that the trailer accurately reflects the film’s quality.
I have this nagging feeling that Cameron Crowe isn’t any good. This is unfair of me, because I’ve only seen a few of his movies, but nagging feelings don’t need to be fair. In 2005, I was offered the chance to interview Cameron Crowe for the GW student newspaper about his then-new film Elizabethtown, which is, by nearly all accounts, hot garbage. I turned it down so I could watch Game 5 of the American League Division Series between the Yankees and Angels. The Yankees lost. I still don’t regret this, because, assuming that I felt the same way about Elizabethtown as almost everybody else does, interviewing him about it would have been wild awkward.
I’m on my guard these days: I usually read all the spoilers for seemingly crazy movies like this one, since I’d never see it of my own volition. But I’ve been holding off lately. While I've read a few reviews and had a cursory glance at the Emma Stone stuff linked earlier, I decided to remain unspoiled on the major plot points of Aloha, knowing that one of you jerks might up and make me watch it at any time. And verily, it came to pass.
Plot summary and trailer yoinked from IMDb and YouTube, respectively: “A celebrated military contractor returns to the site of his greatest career triumphs and reconnects with a long-ago love while unexpectedly falling for the hard-charging Air Force watchdog assigned to him.”
What I thought of the movie: I’m on record as saying that I like ambitious movies, and Aloha was certainly ambitious. It wanted me to laugh, cry, think, and nod in approval, to be awed by its cleverness and moved by its profundity. It wanted to say meaningful things about love, family, second chances, heritage, America, and the military-industrial complex. It did not succeed at any of these things. It did succeed in making me physically angry. I am hereby suspending my “I like ambitious movies” rule.
Chief among the many problems that this movie had (and it should be noted that the plot of this movie was insane and convoluted to a degree that just about defies description) was its dialogue. Vincent pointed out some of the worst, faux-cool one-liners in the trailer, and there are certainly many, many more of those in the rest of the movie; the one that I somehow had the wherewithal to write down was, “You sold your soul so many times, nobody’s buying anymore.” Sick burn.
But the main issue for me was that the characters don’t talk like real people talk. Sometimes that’s fine; the characters in All About Eve, for example, definitely don’t talk like real people talk. But they’re also very strong, believable, understandable characters. The characters in this movie are none of those things. They’re either tossing off pithy one-liners, like the ones noted earlier, or they’re intently articulating exactly how they’re feeling at that moment. Every line is meant to be either effortlessly cool or impossibly deep. So many things are said in this movie, and so few of them are things that actual people would say, even under the ridiculous circumstances in which the movie places them.
For example: Rachel McAdams, who has been married to John Krasinski’s character for twelve years, sees Bradley Cooper, whom she dated thirteen years earlier, and within a day of seeing him again is telling him, in detail, how dissatisfied she is with her marriage WHILE HER HUSBAND IS IN THE NEXT ROOM. She’s not even keeping her voice down! And the reason for this is that Crowe needs us to know how McAdams feels, and he doesn't trust her ability to express emotions like “dissatisfaction” non-verbally. It's almost insulting. (Side note: don’t get me wrong, I love John Krasinski [and not just because his name is v similar to mine], but he plays a hulking, laconic brute of a soldier here, which is something else. “We need to cast the role of a big, tough soldier. Get me the guy from The Office who smirked to the camera every five minutes.”)
Anyway. Listening to the movie made my head hurt. You can feel Crowe swinging for the fences, trying to write the next “Show me the money” or “You complete me” or “You had me at ‘hello’” or whatever, and it just all goes so wrong. Like, he thought it was a good idea to have Bradley Cooper say, “I go hard, I go deep, and sometimes I break things.” And that’s not even meant to be a sexy line! You could replace the dialogue from this movie with dialogue from an entirely different movie, and it would make almost as much sense.
The plot, as noted, is no less crazy. Every action that everyone takes revolves around Bradley Cooper’s character for no reason. Crowe does little to convince us why he’s so important to all of these disparate characters. Bill Murray (who is so wasted in this movie, in every sense of the term) keeps him around for no reason. Emma Stone falls for him instantly for no reason. Rachel McAdams emotionally cheats on her husband with him for no reason. In fact, the entire romantic side of the multi-sided plot is just a long set-up for Cooper’s character to have to choose between two unbelievably beautiful women whom he does not deserve. Must be nice.
The movie’s various plot lines are picked up and discarded at random. For a while it seems like the movie is going to be a paean to Hawaii, featuring members of its proud independence movement, but they disappear after one scene. Then it seems like it’s going to be about the insidious public-private partnerships that threaten our national security, and then it’s a love story, and then it’s a paternity story, and on and on. There's a whole climax involving a satellite that's one of the dumbest things I've ever seen, a climax that is written off as an afterthought three scenes later. It’s dizzying.
If I’m not doing a good job of explaining to you why it made me so angry, it’s because there were just too many things for me to write down. But I found that most of my scribbled, serial-killer-esque notes dealt with just how unreal the people in this movie felt. And the worst part is that I really think that this is Crowe's true ambition. He's actually going for “unreal.” This is why all the Emma Stone controversy makes sense to me: actually having a Hawaiian actress play her part would have tethered the movie too closely to real life, and Crowe doesn’t want that. He wants Aloha be better than real life, and having had to spend two hours of my real life watching it, I can tell you that it's far, far worse.
Am I happy I took Vincent’s recommendation? Uh, no. Ha!
What’s next?
UPDATE: Known tween Lindsay Filardo has recommended One Direction: This Is Us. I would copy and paste what I just wrote to her on Gchat, but this is a family blog.
UPDATE: Known tween Lindsay Filardo has recommended One Direction: This Is Us. I would copy and paste what I just wrote to her on Gchat, but this is a family blog.